Datapages, Inc.Print this page

PSUnder-Saturation in Coals: How Does It Happen and Why Is It Important*

By

Robert A. Lamarre1

 

Search and Discovery Article #40195 (2006)

Posted May 22, 2006

 

*Oral Presentation at Rocky Mountain Section AAPG Annual Meeting, Jackson, Wyoming, September 24-26, 2005. Appreciation is expressed to Lyn George, Technical Program Chair, and Don French, for encouraging the author to submit this presentation.

 

Click to view presentation in PDF format (2.6 mb).

 

1Lamarre Geological Enterprises, Denver, CO ([email protected])

 

Abstract 

By combining gas content data with an adsorption isotherm, it is possible to determine the gas saturation condition of a coal sample. Fully saturated coals are ideal from a CBM perspective because they will produce gas immediately as soon as water is produced from the reservoir. As the gas saturation level decreases, more water needs to be produced in order to reduce the reservoir pressure to the critical desorption pressure when gas will start to desorb from the coal.  

In highly under-saturated coal reservoirs, many months to years may be required to sufficiently dewater the coals to allow the desorption process to begin. This long dewatering time can ultimately result in an uneconomic prospect due to long period of little or no cash flow accompanied by ongoing operating expenses.  

Determination of the gas saturation condition is relatively easy and inexpensive. By collection this data early in the life of a CBM project, much time, effort, and money can potentially be saved.  

Under-saturated coal reservoirs may eventually produce large volumes of gas once the reservoir pressure has been reduced to the critical desorption pressure. However, the economics of these reservoirs may be marginal at best. Unfortunately, data collected from many Rocky Mountain CBM prospects indicate that the coals are significantly under-saturated. Examples of some of these prospects, with associated gas and water production data, are presented.

 

 

uAbstract

uFigures

uImportance

uWhy under-saturated

uWhy fully saturated

uExamples

uConclusions

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

uAbstract

uFigures

uImportance

uWhy under-saturated

uWhy fully saturated

uExamples

uConclusions

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

uAbstract

uFigures

uImportance

uWhy under-saturated

uWhy fully saturated

uExamples

uConclusions

 

Selected Figures

 

Why is Under-Saturation Important? 

  • We have no control over this parameter.

  • Requires producing large volumes of water.

  • Results in delay of desorption of gas from coal.

  • Increases payout time.

  • Delays positive cash flow.

  • Results in decreased reserves (Figure 1).

  • Requires abundant patience (and money).

 

Why are Some Coals Under-Saturated? 

  • Most mature coals were originally fully-saturated

BUT

  • Coals lose gas as reservoir pressure is reduced, due to:

    • Uplift (Figure 2)

    • Faulting

    • Unconformities

AND

  • Coals can store more gas at lower temperatures after a basin is uplifted. 

 

Why Are Some Coal Reservoirs Fully-Saturated? 

Coals can become fully saturated when more gas is added due to secondary biogenic gas generation and migration of biogenic and thermogenic gases (Figure 3).

 

Examples 

Eastern margin of Washakie Basin (Figure 4), where hydrodynamics is partially  responsible for the high gas content, with downdip flow from meteoric recharge and updip flow from hydrocarbon recharge. 

South flank of Uinta Basin (Figure 5), where thermogenic gas has moved updip. 

Northwest flank of San Rafael Swell (Figure 6), where biogenic gas has migrated updip.

 

Conclusions 

  • Fully saturated coal reservoirs are rare.

  • Under-saturated coals will produce abundant water before making gas.

  • Under-saturated coals require patience.

  • Under-saturated coals may not be economic.

  • CBM exploration programs should focus on areas where additional thermogenic and/or biogenic gas has re-saturated the coals.

Return to top.